Valley Blog

Valley® Irrigation is the worldwide leader in precision irrigation. The Valley brand of center pivot, linear, and corner equipment provides solutions for conserving water and meeting the growing demand for food.

Center Pivot Irrigation vs. Flood Irrigation, Part 2: Return of the Sprinklers

by User Not Found | Jun 05, 2018

Editor’s note: A few weeks ago, we ran a blog about the merits of center pivot irrigation as compared to flood irrigation. You can find it here. This is Part 2 in our series, which more closely examines the role of sprinklers in irrigation management.

Center pivot irrigation runs circles (if you’ll pardon the pun) around other methods of crop irrigation, such as flood irrigation. To examine this statement closer, let’s consider several key points between center pivot irrigation sprinkler systems and flood irrigation.

Water, Soil and Work

center-pivotValley® center pivots are built to last, but the grower is still the most vital piece.

There is a finite amount of fresh water in this world, and each farmer has a limited number of days and dollars to invest and bring his crop to market. Given the limitations, what irrigation method should a successful farmer invest his time, finances and natural resources in?

Since the beginning of domestic farming, ancient farmers used flood irrigation. Today, farmers still flood their fields to water their crops. It is a simple method, but one that is labor intensive, and not very efficient.

In order to get the right amount of irrigation water at the end of the flood-irrigated field, the field must be over-watered at the beginning of the flood run. More water than the crop requires will soak into – and sometimes through – the soil profile at the beginning of a leveled flood field to get the desired water application at the end of the flood run.

Irrigation Sprinklers: Proven by Research

sprinkler-close-upPictured: the Senninger iWob sprinkler provides efficient use of water and even application.

Research performed by scientists at the University of California-Davis evaluated and compared center pivot irrigation sprinklers to furrow flood irrigation. Their tests showed that 30 percent less water was applied with center pivot irrigation than furrow irrigation, while still achieving comparable results. Other research has shown that on fields with extremely light, sandy soils, only about half of the water used ends up benefitting crops. That is a lot of wasted water!

Another of the inescapable consequences of flood irrigation is the leaching of nitrogen and other chemicals into the groundwater. The uniform application pattern and depth of center pivot sprinkler irrigation systems decreases leaching significantly, which is good news in both economic and environmental terms.

To facilitate water movement from one end of a field to the other, flood irrigation only works effectively on laser-leveled fields. Leveling requires many man hours and expensive machine hours, and can result in a change of soil characteristics. Center pivots, on the other hand, can negotiate complex topography that would never be able to be flood irrigated. Center pivots can transverse a wide variety of terrain from gently rolling hills to extremely steep slopes.

Flood irrigation requires extreme field tillage to bury crop debris, and that often leads to soil erosion caused by wind and rain. Center pivot irrigation sprinklers actually deliver improved water distribution and increased efficiency of water usage with “no-till” crop residue retention practices. Center pivot sprinkler irrigation systems conserve soil by significantly reducing the need for field tillage.

Labor Daze

grower-with-pivotSaving your operation time means your operation saves money. Upgrading to center pivot or linear irrigation can save any operation both.

Flood irrigation is very labor intensive, and farmers are finding it more and more difficult to hire people who want to do the kind of labor needed for flood irrigation. There is a lot of pipe to lay at the beginning of the season, take up at the end of the season, and store until the next growing season. Between planting and harvest, the flood farmer will need to keep checking gates and tubes, walking rows, ditching and damming. In contrast, using center pivots that incorporate modern automation will reduce accompanying labor costs by close to 90 percent.

When compared to flood/gravity irrigation practices, the precise, uniform water application provided by center pivot irrigation sprinklers often results in higher crop yields. Combining the reduction of water use with pumping energy cost reductions, center pivot sprinkler irrigation delivers solid economic benefits. And with increasing shortages of farm labor, the convenience of center pivot irrigation will continue to be an effective long-term management tool for the successful modern farmer.

To take full advantage of the superior water delivery provided by the irrigation sprinklers on center pivots, contact your local Valley dealer today.

About Clark Robeson, CID

Sr. Water Application Specialist
Valley Irrigation

Certified Irrigation Designer – Irrigation Association

Clark has dedicated the last 22 years of his 42-year tenure with Valmont Industries working directly with Valley North American and global center pivot dealers. Clark trains and educates Valley dealers to create optimum water application packages that fit a grower’s climate, soil, crops and resources. Clark is very proud that his professional efforts help save water by efficiently distributing water to crops that feed a hungry world. In his leisure time, Clark enjoys helping his wife with her flower gardens and pursuing his hobby of classic Mustang and antique automobiles.